The moment I saw a picture of The Cookie Mill's ice cream cookie sandwich, I kept thinking about it randomly. At work... during my workout... when going to sleep... Now that I have finally had one (I selected vanilla ice cream between two decadent dark chocolate white chocolate chip cookies), I still keep thinking about it! It was so delicious! It was also only $3.00.
Large cookies are 75 cents each or $5.00 for one dozen. I tried the seven varieties they had available: dark chocolate with white chocolate chips, oatmeal raisin, oatmeal chocolate chip, chocolate chip, sugar, snickerdoodle, and peanut butter. All cookies were chewy, thin, soft, and buttery. The dark chocolate cookie (strong chocolate flavor- yum!) was definitely the best with the oatmeal chocolate chip (chewy with crispy edges) and regular chocolate chip (very buttery with lots of chocolate chips) a close second and third. The snickerdoodle and peanut butter cookies were average, but would satisfy a craving for that particular kind of cookie. The sugar cookie was rather dull and didn't have a lot of flavor in comparison with the others. The oatmeal raisin had too many raisins for me.
The Cookie Mill is located at 1165 East Alosta Avenue in Azusa. Visit www.cookiemill.com for more information.